The questionnaire
Answered, with evidence behind every yes.
For small businesses without an IT person
Your cyber insurance application asks whether things are true that nobody at your company can check. I check them, fix what isn’t, and give you answers you can sign.
Cyber insurance is the policy that pays when someone gets into your IT systems and wreaks havoc: ransomware, a hijacked email account, a wire sent to the wrong place. If you carry this coverage, it’s probably because your broker suggested it or a customer required it, and it may be an add-on to your main business policy. Either way, every renewal comes with an application full of yes-or-no questions about how your systems are set up.
Insurance carriers often scan what they can see of your systems before a policy starts, and check the rest when you file a claim. A ‘yes’ on that questionnaire that wasn’t true can void the policy.
If you have an IT person and a broker who walks you through the application, you’re probably covered. This is for businesses that have neither.
There are two ways in. Ninety to 120 days before renewal, a two-week audit: I work remotely inside your Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, check every control the application asks about, fix what I can, and hand you the application answered with evidence behind every yes. If your quote has already come back with conditions, a three-to-five-day response that clears them. Either way, you give me an administrator account, and it’s deleted when I’m done.
What you’re signing
In March 2022 an electronics manufacturer in Illinois signed a cyber insurance application and an attestation that it used multi-factor authentication. The policy started in April. In May the company was hit with ransomware. When the carrier looked, multi-factor sign-in was on the firewall and nowhere else. The carrier went to federal court to void the policy, and in August both sides agreed: null and void from the day it started, no coverage for anything. The company had been insured for about a month. Before your policy starts, the carrier scans what it can see of your systems from the outside. What it can’t see, like whether multi-factor sign-in is actually enforced or whether your backups actually restore, gets checked when you file a claim.
SOURCE: TRAVELERS V. INTERNATIONAL CONTROL SERVICES, U.S. DISTRICT COURT, CENTRAL DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS, 2022The checklist
The questions vary by carrier, but they all come down to nine things. Here they are in the words carriers use, with what “yes” really means for each.
Multi-factor sign-in on email, remote access, and administrator accounts. Yes means it’s enforced for everyone, not available to anyone who wants it.
Backups. How often, protected so an attacker inside your network can’t delete them, and restored from at least once so you know they work.
Endpoint protection on every machine. Not just the ones in the office, the disks encrypted, and you can name the product.
Email protection. Authentication on your domain so your name can’t be used to phish your customers, and filtering turned on so the obvious junk never reaches an inbox.
A list of who has administrator access. And a step that removes it the day someone leaves.
Remote access to your systems. Every path in requires multi-factor sign-in, and the ones nobody uses anymore are turned off.
A written incident response plan. With a name and a phone number in it.
Security awareness training. With a record of who took it and when.
A rule for changing payment details. Anyone asking to change where money goes gets a call back on a number you already had.
Most businesses I’ve looked at can honestly say yes to about half of these. The audit is for the other half.
How it works
Week one
You send me the policy, last year’s application, and administrator access to email, files, backups, and the domain. I go control by control and check what’s actually in place, not what someone remembers setting up.
Week two
I fix the administrative gaps myself. Turn on multi-factor sign-in and enforce it. Fix the domain records. Write the incident response plan and the policies the carrier expects to exist. Set up offboarding so access ends when employment does. Then I write up what’s left and who should handle it.
No slide deck. No recommendations document that sends you looking for someone to act on it.
If your quote came back with conditions
Send me the quote, the list of conditions, and an administrator account on day one. Within three to five business days you have an answer to each condition, with evidence, ready for your broker to send back.
What you get
Answered, with evidence behind every yes.
Sorted three ways: fixed, you can do this yourself, get outside help for this.
The ones carriers expect to exist: incident response plan, acceptable use, access and offboarding, backup procedure.
One page for the night something happens: carrier, broker, bank, whoever handles your systems.
For a Quote Conditions Response, you get a written answer to each condition with evidence, whatever I could fix inside the window, and a list of anything that needs its own project.
The price
Your policy probably pays out a million dollars or more if something goes wrong. This is what it costs to make sure your answers on the application aren’t the reason it doesn’t.
Before the application goes in
Two weeks. Best started 90 to 120 days before your renewal.
After the quote comes back
Three to five business days. For when the carrier sends conditions you have to clear before the policy starts, or after a decline.
$500 for each condition after that. Paid up front.
The fixes I do happen inside your Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace and your domain. Anything that needs hands on hardware, like a firewall, a server, or a laptop, goes on the list as its own project, at the prices on my services menu.
Then, if you want it: $350 a month to keep it current. I check it monthly, fix what’s drifted, and redo the questionnaire when renewal comes around. It’s the same monthly care I offer for anything I’ve set up.
What this isn’t
This isn’t a security audit and it isn’t penetration testing. It doesn’t guarantee the carrier pays a claim. If something needs a security firm, the report says so and names what to look for. And I never fill out or sign your application; you do. This is the operational review of the things the application asks about, done by someone who runs operations for a living.
I’ve done this before
A pipeline contractor and an equipment dealer, both on Microsoft 365, both with a renewal coming and nobody who could say what was actually turned on. I found multi-factor sign-in enforced for some people and not others, a backup nobody had ever restored from, and an incident response plan that existed as an intention. Two weeks later both had every one of those fixed, the paperwork the carrier expects, and an application they could sign without guessing. Nothing about either business was unusual. That’s the point.
Who I am
I’m Greg Hoy. I’m not a broker and I don’t sell IT. Twelve of these years were spent running a 45-person agency, and all of them as the person who held the admin passwords. Earlier on I worked at Safeco Insurance in Seattle, building the web systems customers used to buy and manage their policies. That was property and casualty, not cyber, and I wasn’t an underwriter. But I’ve seen how the business works from the inside, and the rule is the same everywhere: the carrier believes what you signed until the day it has a reason not to.
More about meBefore you ask
Is it safe to give you the keys? You create an administrator account for me on Day 1 and delete it on Day 14. Every change I make is listed in the report. Nothing is hidden and nothing is permanent.
How much of my time does this take? About two hours of yours for the audit: a short call at the start, a few questions by email, and a walk through the report at the end. The two weeks are mine. A conditions response takes less: one short call and a few emails.
Do you talk to my carrier? No. I never contact your carrier or your broker. The report is yours; send it to whoever you want, or nobody.
What if most of my answers are no? Then you’re normal. Most of it gets fixed before you see the report, and what’s left comes with a plain explanation of what it would take.
My quote already came back with conditions. Am I too late? No. That’s what the Quote Conditions Response is for. Send me the quote and I’ll tell you within one business day what I can clear and how long it will take.
Ask about the audit
I’ll reply within one business day with the agreement and a payment link. If you’d rather talk first, there’s a scheduler below.